greybing, on 08 November 2011 - 18:28 , said:
Why do snow flakes form in the same geometric pattern,ie hexgonal is it?However many sides it is they always have I wonder if anybody knows why and can explain articulately.
They don't and I don't think you will get a definitive answer to this. This may help. The source is
H2O: A Biography of Water by Philip Ball. Well worth a read.
"In the 1930s, Ukichiro Nakaya at Hokkaido University in Japan developed techniques for growing snowflakes artificially in the laboratory, allowing him to explore systematically how shape and form vary with the conditions of growth. These studies showed that, for all their variety, the 'six-petalled flowers' are just one breed of a whole menagerie of forms. Nakaya and his coworkers grew the ice crystals on a rabbit's hair suspended within a stream of moist air, in a chamber placed within a room that could be cooled to minus 30°C. The main influence on the crystal shape is the temperature, although varying the humidity of the air can also affect the shape. At around 0 to -3°C, the snowflakes are 'plates' -flat flakes of ice with hexagonal shapes. Between about -3 and -SoC, they take on a needle-like form instead. At lower temperatures down to about -22 to -25°C, plates are formed if the air is not too moist, whereas dendritic stars and other complex forms appear in more moist air. If it is colder still, prismatic crystals appear. Much the same relationships have been observed in the real atmosphere. A feeling for snow is, it seems, in large measure a feeling for coldness and humidity.
A continuing mystery about dendritic snowflakes is why all six of their branches seem to be more or less identical. The theory of dendritic growth explains why the side branches will develop at certain angles, but it contains no guarantee that they will all appear at eqUivalent places on different branches, or will grow to the same dimensions; indeed, these branching events are expected to happen at random. Yet snowflakes can present astonishing examples of coordination, as if each branch knows what the other is doing. One hypothesis is that vibrations of the crystal lattice bounce back and forth through the crystal like standing waves in an organ pipe, providing a degree of coordination and communication in the growth process. Another is that the apparent similarity of the arms is illusory, a result of the spatial constraints imposed because all the branches grow close together ar more or less the same rate. But for the present the secret of the snowflake endures".
Edited by weather ship, 09 November 2011 - 00:34 .