Jump to content
Snow?
Local
Radar
Cold?
IGNORED

Rob Mcelwee's Last Shift Is Tonight Folks - Last Forecast Is At 10.52Pm Bbc One :( End Of An Era.


Cymro

Is this a bad move by the Beeb?  

162 members have voted

  1. 1. Do you think this decision is the correct thing to do?

    • No Way - Very bad move
      155
    • Not sure - cut's have to be made
      5
    • Yes - too much of a cold ramper
      2


Recommended Posts

Posted
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)
  • Weather Preferences: Thunderstorms
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)

But he still has a job, just behind the scenes I believe. It's not as if he's currently queuing up at the dole office!

Indeed, but its not really the point. When I watch a forecast I like to be well informed as well as entertained, even though forecasting is not about entertainment. The fact that he can provided knowledge, interest and entertainment whereas a number of forecasts struggle with just one of those criterion, I find exceptionally frustrating.

His axing along with Avery and Schafernaker smacks with politics and not business sensibility!

Edited by Harry
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Melbourne, Victoria
  • Location: Melbourne, Victoria

This is sad.

He is without a doubt the most the straightforward in his explnaations of the weather. He doesn't patronise, he is clear and specific in his presentation style.

I don't know if anyone else has the same problem as me, with some of the forecasters, i simply automatically switch off when they start speaking and the end of the forecast arrives and i suddenly snap out of it and think "damn - what was the forecast again?"

With Rob you never get that. He holds your attention.

It's a great skill and a great loss that we're losing it from our screens.

Edited by Upgrade
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Bratislava, Slovakia
  • Location: Bratislava, Slovakia
His axing along with Avery and Schafernaker smacks with politics and not business sensibility!

I can only assume Schafernaker doomed himself with the finger incident. No idea why Philip Avery and Rob McElwee would be deemed more unsuitable than the others: they could have just picked names out of a hat for all I know.

Edited by AderynCoch
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)
  • Weather Preferences: Thunderstorms
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)

I can only assume Shafernaker doomed himself with the finger incident.

No idea why Philip Avery and Rob McElwee would be deemed more unsuitable than the others: they could have just picked names out of a hat for all I know.

Well, I can say albeit with no real certainty, that it has nothing to do with the fact they are ageing men and not young, handsome eye candy that will draw in more viewers.

This is sad.

He is without a doubt the most the straightforward in his explnaations of the weather. He doesn't patronise, he is clear and specific in his presentation style.

I don't know if anyone else has the same problem as me, with some of the forecasters, i simply automatically switch off when they start speaking and the end of the forecast arrives and i suddenly snap out of it and think "damn - what was the forecast again?"

With Rob you never get that. He holds your attention.

It's a great skill and a great loss that we're losing it from our screens.

Exactly that Upgrade...I find some BBC forecasters patronising and quite condescending at times...some forecasters seem to think they are presenting CBeebies and have an audience with an average age of 4 years old - Rob is always concise, talks to his viewers like they have some common sense and always admits up front if there is doubt, whether its guesswork and sometimes even throws in his own penny's worth by saying "I think...."...some however talk like robots, maintaining it WILL rain, it WILL snow, it WILL be dry, only to change it 30 mins later by saying it WILL be this, it WILL be that...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Herne Bay, Kent
  • Location: Herne Bay, Kent

Would be great if we could sign Rob up to the forum.

Perhaps BBC South East Today could sign him up to join Sir Fish? B)

YES PLEASE....It is ridiculous I wish he would replace the HIGHLY IRRITATING lee-Preston.<_<

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Whaley Bridge - Peak District
  • Location: Whaley Bridge - Peak District

When you hear Sky News weather Presenters saying nonsentical terms as "Mountain Snow for the South" or realise the vast majority of presenters as Eno Erutor have no degree in Meteorology whatsoever. It just boggles the mind as to what is behind the driving force that's ousting the professionals such as McElwee, Avery and Fish.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Shepton Mallet 140m ASL
  • Weather Preferences: Cold, snow and summer heatwaves.
  • Location: Shepton Mallet 140m ASL

Very sad and very disapointed! He was with out a doubt the best forecaster they had!

true legend. :smiliz23:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Northampton (90m ASL)
  • Location: Northampton (90m ASL)

Sadly it looks like nobody captured Rob's final BBC One forecast. However, someone did manage to capture his final edition of Weatherview late last night (his final broadcast, but presumably prerecorded).

http://www.tvforum.co.uk/thenewsroom/the-weather-thread-28723/page-37 (2nd post down)

At least the BBC announcer acknowledged it.

Edited by NorthantsSnow
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Putney, SW London. A miserable 14m asl....but nevertheless the lucky recipient of c 20cm of snow in 12 hours 1-2 Feb 2009!
  • Location: Putney, SW London. A miserable 14m asl....but nevertheless the lucky recipient of c 20cm of snow in 12 hours 1-2 Feb 2009!

This website - which, unknown to me, has for a long time had a section, "Cloudy Language", celebrating the linguistic glories of (mainly) Rob and other weather presenters - bids him farewell with this fine tribute: http://asburyandasbury.typepad.com/blog/cloudy-language/

Read down the whole page, there's a feast of great stuff there.

Edited by osmposm
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Windermere 120m asl
  • Location: Windermere 120m asl

When you hear Sky News weather Presenters saying nonsentical terms as "Mountain Snow for the South" or realise the vast majority of presenters as Eno Erutor have no degree in Meteorology whatsoever. It just boggles the mind as to what is behind the driving force that's ousting the professionals such as McElwee, Avery and Fish.

I always assumed all BBC weather presenters held a degree in meterology and were at least sub script writers for the presentations they present - how naive. Mind, Eno Erutor on NW weather usually gets all her words mixed up, on many occasions she delivers a really poor forecast, she is getting better but sometimes she just makes me laugh.

Sometimes I watch old BBC weather forecasts from yesteryear, when the likes of Michael Fish, Ian M, Bernard Davey, John Kettley and Bill Giles delivered the forecasts. They were far superior than many of today's presenters, and often stuck their nexk out and gave there own views about conditions, today's presenters seem too scared to do this, or should I say there is now probably a list of do's and not to say's. The forecasts have becme very political, especially in the summer when there seems to be an urgency to emphasise the slighest hint of summery weather - it does good for the economy etc... its the same in the winter, when they over emphasise how good mild weather will be, almost naive to the fact that on nine times out of ten it is accompanied by dull dark leaden skies and heavy rain and strong winds, generally not what the vast public enjoys..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)
  • Weather Preferences: Thunderstorms
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)

I always assumed all BBC weather presenters held a degree in meterology and were at least sub script writers for the presentations they present - how naive. Mind, Eno Erutor on NW weather usually gets all her words mixed up, on many occasions she delivers a really poor forecast, she is getting better but sometimes she just makes me laugh.

Sometimes I watch old BBC weather forecasts from yesteryear, when the likes of Michael Fish, Ian M, Bernard Davey, John Kettley and Bill Giles delivered the forecasts. They were far superior than many of today's presenters, and often stuck their nexk out and gave there own views about conditions, today's presenters seem too scared to do this, or should I say there is now probably a list of do's and not to say's. The forecasts have becme very political, especially in the summer when there seems to be an urgency to emphasise the slighest hint of summery weather - it does good for the economy etc... its the same in the winter, when they over emphasise how good mild weather will be, almost naive to the fact that on nine times out of ten it is accompanied by dull dark leaden skies and heavy rain and strong winds, generally not what the vast public enjoys..

The biggest irony is that of late, its the MetO who have been getting the slamming from the media, firstly for their 2009 BBQ summer (which I maintain we pretty much had here in the SE, although local memory appears to have faded with most) but also now for failing to forewarn of the snow chaos through late Nov/December 2010. Sometimes they can't win -

But really, it just goes to show, that when it is all so unpredictable, I see really very little reason why more subjective comments and input cannot be given...the weather is fickle and very unpredictable...it's better to get a hint that the forecasters don't have a clue but suspect A, rather than say B will definitely happen whilst leave everyone disappointed when it doesn't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Teston, Kent (3mls SW of Maidstone)
  • Location: Teston, Kent (3mls SW of Maidstone)

I was aghast and saddened to hear this. Rob McElwee did sometimes have a habit of speaking to his audience as if they were into weather as a hobby. However that's what made him peculiarly distinctive - you always felt he was an enthusiast who was was doing this as much for enjoyment as a job. Yes he obviously liked cold but equally he enjoyed summer thunder and all the other more extreme events that no doubt most members of this site are enthused by. He has been a TV forecaster for very many years (though I think he took a break at one stage for a while) and was highly recognisable. This decision is remarkably disrespectful to a loyal servant and when you look at the three who have been removed from our screens can you honestly say they are worse media performers in any way than those who remain (one or two of whom are rather tedious, are called Darren and fairly or unfairly are known to be mild rampers!). Viewers actually like characters on screen (like Rob Mc and T Shaf) and once again the BBC are doing themselves no favours.

Edit. I appreciate it's the Met Office rather than the Beeb directly but perhaps they should note the Miriam O'Reilly ageism case that I'm pleased to see Miriam won today.

Edited by Kentish Man
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)
  • Weather Preferences: Thunderstorms
  • Location: Bexley (home), C London (work)

I was aghast and saddened to hear this. Rob McElwee did sometimes have a habit of speaking to his audience as if they were into weather as a hobby. However that's what made him peculiarly distinctive - you always felt he was an enthusiast who was was doing this as much for enjoyment as a job. Yes he obviously liked cold but equally he enjoyed summer thunder and all the other more extreme events that no doubt most members of this site are enthused by. He has been a TV forecaster for very many years (though I think he took a break at one stage for a while) and was highly recognisable. This decision is remarkably disrespectful to a loyal servant and when you look at the three who have been removed from our screens can you honestly say they are worse media performers in any way than those who remain (one or two of whom are rather tedious, are called Darren and fairly or unfairly are known to be mild rampers!). Viewers actually like characters on screen (like Rob Mc and T Shaf) and once again the BBC are doing themselves no favours.

Edit. I appreciate it's the Met Office rather than the Beeb directly but perhaps they should note the Miriam O'Reilly ageism case that I'm pleased to see Miriam won today.

Re: Miriam...all I kept thinking about was Rob McElwee and Phil Avery when that came into the news. Cynical it may be, but I can't help but think Schafernaker has been axed because he is young, so as to disguise the, what seems to me, blatant ageism in getting rid of McElwee and Avery from front line forecasting...BBC are for me a bit of a joke - they think they're cunning but I would just love the three of them to launch a case against them!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Lincoln, Lincolnshire
  • Weather Preferences: Sunshine, convective precipitation, snow, thunderstorms, "episodic" months.
  • Location: Lincoln, Lincolnshire

It's a shame to see all three of them go really, I think Thomas Schafemaker was also pretty good on the Countryfile broadcasts, despite the occasional mess-up. I don't think we're ever likely to know the real reasons in full. There are still some good ones left- one name that I haven't seen mentioned recently is Peter Gibbs, I haven't seen much of him recently but he's always been pretty good.

Sadly I agree with much of what Damianslaw says above, though the forecasts I saw over Christmas 2010 seemed to have rather less of the "hopefully X, at least Y" type subjectivity than the Christmas 2009 ones- coincidence or a trend?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Teston, Kent (3mls SW of Maidstone)
  • Location: Teston, Kent (3mls SW of Maidstone)

Re: Miriam...all I kept thinking about was Rob McElwee and Phil Avery when that came into the news. Cynical it may be, but I can't help but think Schafernaker has been axed because he is young, so as to disguise the, what seems to me, blatant ageism in getting rid of McElwee and Avery from front line forecasting...BBC are for me a bit of a joke - they think they're cunning but I would just love the three of them to launch a case against them!

Axing Schafernaker with the other two in order to disguise blatant ageism had occurred to me as well. Schafernaker was a bit of a loose cannon so his axing served a duel purpose no doubt. However at least he was mildly entertaining unlike the identikit cast of Ridge, Tobin, Bett et al who have been on our screens this week. There are a few good ones left - Dan Corbett, Hammond, Gibbs and of course Helen Willetts but if you take the BBC TV weather presenters as a group there are now very few much over 40 years of age. This can't be good in a profession where experience is invaluable.

Edited by Kentish Man
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted
  • Location: Near Horsham, West Sussex
  • Location: Near Horsham, West Sussex

as you know i started the 1st save rob thread a few months back.

ive been away the last week and missed his last show.

im so up set!! please check out my youtube film i made in support of rob and its never to late write to the met office and tell them to bring rob back!

gosh what a shock, i just hope he was happy, how will i ever watch the weather again!!!!.......seriously i was a huge fan and i dont think following weather will be the same for me again.

Edited by Westsussex1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • UK Storm and Severe Convective Forecast

    UK Severe Convective & Storm Forecast - Issued 2024-03-29 07:13:16 Valid: 29/03/2024 0600 - 30/03/2024 0600 THUNDERSTORM WATCH - FRI 29 MARCH 2024 Click here for the full forecast

    Nick F
    Nick F
    Latest weather updates from Netweather

    Difficult travel conditions as the Easter break begins

    Low Nelson is throwing wind and rain at the UK before it impacts mainland Spain at Easter. Wild condtions in the English Channel, and more rain and lightning here on Thursday. Read the full update here

    Netweather forecasts
    Netweather forecasts
    Latest weather updates from Netweather

    UK Storm and Severe Convective Forecast

    UK Severe Convective & Storm Forecast - Issued 2024-03-28 09:16:06 Valid: 28/03/2024 0800 - 29/03/2024 0600 SEVERE THUNDERSTORM WATCH - THURS 28 MARCH 2024 Click here for the full forecast

    Nick F
    Nick F
    Latest weather updates from Netweather
×
×
  • Create New...